Kelly Starr guides publicly traded and private companies, governing boards and their committees, executives and management teams through all aspects of executive compensation and employee benefits matters.
Combining in-house human resources experience with 30 years in private practice, she negotiates a variety of executive agreements, drafts contracts, compensation plans and collaborates with clients for maximum results.
Kelly’s collaborative approach and depth of experience help clients avoid legal missteps and manage the full spectrum of benefit and compensation plans. Companies lean on her to manage executive transitions with little disruption, negotiate executive and employee benefit arrangements in acquisitions and provide executive compensation and employee benefit programs that are user-friendly and compliant. On the executive side, Kelly negotiates on their behalf and provides guidance and context through transitions.
Bringing peace of mind through her practical guidance and technical know-how, Kelly helps clients negotiate executive agreements, including severance, retirement, restrictive covenant and ascension arrangements, as well as compensation plans and executive compensation issues related to M&A deals. Recognizing the negotiating parties may need to preserve their future relationship, she is mindful to keep negotiations professionally collaborative.
Kelly also counsels a variety of employers on all aspects of employee benefits, including qualified and non-qualified retirement plans. She guides clients through the drafting of plan documents and participant communications, compliance issues such as plan governance, government filings, correction actions and plan design changes, and handles vendor contract review.
Kelly has always been sophisticated, knowledgeable, and responsive.
Experience
- Represented a management team of a PE-owned consulting company being sold to a publicly traded company. The members of the management team each had ownership interest in the seller, as well as an employment relationship. Payment terms and restrictive covenants were key issues along with future roles and the contractual terms around them.
- Advised an executive being hired onto an executive team with the expectation of becoming the CEO by a predetermined date. Contractual enforcement mechanisms for progression of the CEO role were key, along with other contractual terms.
- Guided a large management team of a publicly traded company to a significantly larger publicly traded company in the same industry. Various team members took new roles with the buyer, others took temporary roles followed by separation and some team members discontinued employment. Each executive was focused on treatment of equity-based compensation awards, severance protection, and restrictive covenants.
- Guided executive through a separation, after one year in a new executive role, which involved terms of a sizable forgivable loan that had been part of sign-on compensation.
- Represented a special committee of a board in negotiating and drafting a transition agreement for a retiring CEO, addressing a mismatch in treatment of existing incentive compensation at retirement.
Credentials
Education
- University of Illinois College of Law, J.D., cum laude, 1995
- Cornell University, B.S., 1988
Industrial and Labor Relations
Bar Admissions
- Illinois, 1995
Court Admissions
- U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois, 1995
Affiliations
- Member, American Bar Association (Sections on Taxation and Business Law)
- Member, Chicago Bar Association
Recognition
- Best Lawyers in America® – Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law (2017-2026)
- Chambers USA (Illinois) – Employee Benefits & Executive Compensation, Band 3 (2013-2026)
- Leading Lawyers – Employee Benefits Law, Advisory Board (2008-2026)
- The Legal 500 US – Labor and Employment: Employee Benefits, Executive Compensation and Retirement Plans: Design, Recommended Lawyer (2025)
- Super Lawyers – Employee Benefits (2025-2026)
Insights & Events
News
Vedder Practice Areas and Attorneys Recognized in The Legal 500 United States in 2026
June 12, 2026
News
Vedder Recognized in Chambers USA 2026
June 4, 2026
News
26 Vedder Attorneys Recognized in 2026 Illinois Super Lawyers
January 26, 2026
News
76 Vedder Price Attorneys Recognized in 2026 Best Lawyers® in America
August 21, 2025
Deals & Transactions
Vedder Price Represents BankFinancial in Acquisition by First Financial
August 13, 2025
Deals & Transactions
Vedder Price Represents Wynnchurch Capital in Sale of Northstar Aerospace to GE Aerospace
June 30, 2025
News
Vedder Price Practice Areas and Attorneys Recognized in The Legal 500 United States in 2025
June 11, 2025
News
Vedder Price Recognized in Chambers USA in 2025
June 5, 2025
